← All needs

ADRs need a lifecycle — otherwise agents drown in decisions that are no longer true

I use these skills on a real project (test management app, ~1 year old, solo dev + agents). `domain-modeling` and `triage` have been genuinely useful. But I've hit a problem that I think the skills don't have an answer for yet. **We now have 72 ADRs. The skills tell you how to write one. Nothing tells you what happens to it afterwards.** Today I had my agent measure it. The result was worse than I expected: - **11 of 72** were superseded or rejected — and still sitting in `docs/adr/`. So 15% of what an agent reads there is already wrong. - **5 of 7** ADRs marked "Proposed" were actually built and shipped. Nobody had updated the status. So the status field was unreliable in *both* directions: dead things looked alive, and shipped things looked hypothetical. - **8 of 59** active ADRs are referenced by nothing at all — no skill, no code comment, nothing. The cost is two things: 1. **Tokens.** Everything the agent reads, it has to read first. 72 files is not free, and nothing tells it which 3 are relevant to the task at hand. 2. **Wrong direction.** This is the worse one. In one session my agent read an ADR marked "Proposed", concluded the decision had never been built, and reasoned from a picture of the app that hasn't been true for months. The code said otherwise. It only caught it because it happened to check. That second one is the real problem. A stale ADR is not neutral — it actively points the agent somewhere we're not. **What I think is missing is a lifecycle.** Roughly: - A status that has to reflect reality, and ideally can be *checked* against the code rather than trusted - Superseded and rejected ADRs move out of the active folder — they're history, not context - Some way to see which ADRs nobody references, so you can tell "load-bearing but invisible" from "actually dead" I'm not asking for fewer ADRs. Writing them down was right. I'm asking that the skill say what happens to a decision *after* it's written — otherwise the folder just grows, and every agent that opens it pays for decisions that stopped being true a long time ago. Happy to share what we ended up doing on our side if that's useful.